Most portfolio pieces only show the finished shortlist.
A list of names, a visual or two, and a line on each player. It looks finished, and a lot of work has usually gone into it. But it only shows what you found.
At the weekend I posted this on X: "Clubs are hiring how you think, not just what you found."
I want to go a bit further with that here.
Two summers of Forest plans
For two summers in a row, I put together my own Nottingham Forest recruitment plans.
They were well thought through, thorough pieces of work. I reviewed the team, showed where they needed to sign players, found players who suited the playing style, and then found and removed targets based on how well they fitted.
That follows the same process a club goes through.
What I'd want someone to take from them isn't the list of names at the end. It's that they could follow each step and see why I made the decisions I made, from the review of the squad through to the targets I took off the list.
The output is only part of it
The output still matters. Alongside it, you're showing how you think.
That means showing why you did things the way you did in whatever you've built, whether that's your model, your visual or your scouting database.
In the post, I said this: show how you got there, the players you looked at, the data you used to cut the list, and what you watched to check it.
If you removed a target, say why. If a player didn't suit the playing style, say so and explain the reasoning. Someone reading it should be able to see how you'd approach the same work if you were doing it inside a club.
Longer or shorter, it's about consistency
Not every piece has to be a full summer recruitment plan.
Pieces can be longer or shorter. What matters is being consistent, and over time trying to cover all the skills and knowledge you'd need for a club role.
My advice would be this. Next time you finish a piece of work, before you post it, go back through it and add the why behind each choice: why you looked at those players, why you used that data to cut the list, and what you watched to check it.
The finished list shows what you found. The reasoning shows how you think, and that's what clubs are hiring.
Get feedback on how you think
Inside the Recruitment Room you get courses on scouting, recruitment analysis and building your portfolio, weekly live sessions, and feedback on everything you make from me, the mentors and the members.
If you want help getting into football recruitment, you can apply to join the Recruitment Room.